The Best Midsize Luxury Sedans

2022 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Sedan

 


If you’re looking for an efficient and versatile vehicle that exudes class and sophistication, you can’t go wrong with a midsize luxury car. These vehicles handle well, come equipped with dozens of impressive features, and can accommodate either solo drivers or busy families.

Lists of the best midsize luxury sedans can be found all over the web, but we here at Rusnak Auto Group want to make your decision easier, not harder. To that end, we’ve opted to bring you in-depth coverage of the top three contenders, as selected by the independent experts at U.S. News. Let’s get started.

Mercedes-Benz E-Class

The Mercedes-Benz E-Class is a household name for a reason. U.S. News, which aggregates reviews from all over the industry, gave it an overall score of 8.7 out of 10. Here’s why you should choose the E-Class over any other midsize luxury car on the market:

  • The E-Class offers luxury features and appointments that no rival can match. Other luxury sedans are “well-trimmed,” (5 Series) or “well-dressed,” (G80). Meanwhile, the “splendid” E-Class delivers “interior opulence.”
  • Mercedes-Benz has a reputation for excellent ride quality, and they’ve proved their superiority time and time again.
  • The E-Class is offered as a sedan, a coupe, and a convertible—and it can even be had as a wagon. (The wagon has a larger cargo bay, and unlike our other top contenders, it even offers optional seating for up to seven.) This level of customizability is still rare in the luxury car market.

BMW 5 Series

The BMW 5 Series received an overall score of 8.5 out of 10, which earned it the second-best spot in this year’s list of the best luxury midsize sedans. Here’s why it’s an exceptional choice:

  • J.D. Power gave the 5 Series a predicted reliability score of 80 points. That’s an excellent rating—and it’s even higher than that awarded to the E-Class.
  • When the current generation was tested in model-year 2021, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety gave the 5 Series a perfect 10-point score. That’s partly because it comes equipped with even more safety features than the Mercedes-Benz.
  • The 5 Series offers some seriously powerful engines. At the top of the lineup, it offers up to 627 hp—more than almost every other in-class rival.
  • Hoping to spend less on gas? The 5 Series can even be had as a plug-in hybrid vehicle!

Although the BMW offers many advantages over other midsize luxury sedans, it failed to earn the top spot because it “has a fairly conservative interior” that lacks the “visual flair of class rivals.”

Genesis G80

With a total score of 8.5 out of 10, the Genesis G80 is technically tied with the BMW 5 Series! We rank the 5 Series higher because it has a longer history, an optional PHEV powertrain, and more dealership support—but if you’re looking for a less conventional upstart with many obvious strengths, this Genesis sedan is bound to feel like a perfect fit.

  • J.D. Power has given the G80 an even higher reliability score than the BMW: 86 points out of 100. It also comes with ten years of powertrain warranty coverage—much more than you’ll get with either BMW or Mercedes-Benz.
  • Although the Mercedes-Benz sets a higher standard, the G80 provides excellent ride quality. The E-Class and the 5 Series might offer stronger optional engines, but the G80 has more power as standard.
  • There’s one more reward for choosing a less established brand: a lower price!

Top 10 Midsize Luxury Cars: Honorable Mentions

U.S. News goes on to rank the top ten best luxury midsize sedans, and since many of these models can also be found at Rusnak dealerships near Thousand Oaks and Westlake Village, we think you should be aware of all your options:

  1. Audi A6: 8.2
  2. Lexus ES: 8.2
  3. Lexus ES Hybrid: 8.2
  4. Acura TLX: 7.9
  5. Cadillac CT5: 6.9
  6. Jaguar XF: No overall ranking
  7. Volvo S90: No overall ranking

Ready to start exploring your options? Check out our new model inventory today, or continue your research with more of our research guides.

Shop the Best Luxury Midsize Sedans with the Rusnak Auto Group

Whether you lean toward the E-Class, the 5 Series, the G80, or another model entirely, you can find your next luxury vehicle at a Rusnak dealership near Pasadena! We offer an extensive inventory of new luxury vehicles, as well as online shopping tools that can help you take the next steps with confidence!

Saved Vehicles

You don't have any saved vehicles!

Look for this Save icon

Once you've saved some vehicles, you can view them here at any time.

Contact Us


267 W Colorado Boulevard
Pasadena, CA 91105
Rusnak Auto Group 34.146100, -118.156400.